Saturday, August 23, 2014

Pipe Nebula from Canyon of Eagles

I tried out the CCD/Lens combination this evening at Canyon of Eagles. I spent quite some time trying to image Rho Ophiuchi again with this equipment combination. That was a mistake as the target was too low to get good data.  I then picked up a few frames of data on the Pipe Nebula with better results.

This image is taken with Canon EF 70-200mm f/4L lens at about 100mm. I cooled the CCD to -5C with ambient temperature around 32C. I collected 2x900s Luminance frames at 1x1 binning and 2x300s RGB frames at 2x2 binning. Calibration performed with matching dark and bias frames, 10 each.


I did not collect nearly enough color data - only the stars picked up much saturation. However, even with only two stacked frames in each color, the noise level is considerably less that the DSLR.  Focusing without the EOS electronics is still challenging but possible. At 100mm focal length, the peripheral stars are showing some radial elongation, similar to field curvature issues.

I was also able to get a single set of LRGB frames of a field containing the Eagle Nebula and Omega Nebula.


Sunday, August 17, 2014

Mounting QSI-540ws to Canon Lens

This post describes an experiment in connecting my QSI-540ws CCD to my Canon EF lenses. I started this experiment after last month's imaging of Rho Ophiuci. Even with my best attempt at a Peltier cooler box, the image noise was such that I began longing for my CCD camera.

EOS Adapter - My attempts in finding a suitable adapter were frustrating. I ended up purchasing the EOS adapter sold specifically for my QSI-500 series camera. It is designed with the correct spacing from the focal plane but was nearly $200. The adapter is shown in the center of the photo below. Note that this accessory has the opposite polarity of the easily obtained adapter used to attach a DSLR to a telescope.


With all of my Canon DSLR cameras, the bayonet EOS fitting is never as tight as I would like. This one was no different and allowed noticeable rotational play. In order to minimize the chances of this happening while imaging, I cut a strip of craft foam about 3/4" wide and long enough to wrap around the lens barrel. Tightening this down with a Velcro strap, which I glued to the foam with contact cement, provided enough friction across the joint to keep it from twisting. The final assembly is shown below.


Imaging Deck - In an earlier project, I created an imaging deck for a stand-alone, guided DSLR. That version used a ball-mount for the camera, inadequate for the telephoto lens and heavy CCD camera I am trying to use now. In this project, I started by screwing a 4" Vixen dovetail bar to the tripod ring on the lens, as shown above. I mounted an ADM Vixen saddle to the end of a 7" Losmandy dovetail bar. I had to drill and thread two extra 1/4"-20 holes in the saddle for this. I also use a scrap piece of 1/4" thick plastic as a spacer to elevate the saddle enough to clear the large silver knob on the Losmandy-style saddle that came stock on my GM-8. You can see this in the image below. Previously, I had used the ADM dual Vixen/Losmandy saddle with my mount and "machined" a DEC axis spacer-puck to allow it to clear the RA motor assembly. However, after I upgraded the worm gears to the OPWB kit and installed the new motor mounts, the saddle no longer cleared the motor housings. As you can see in the photos, I have kept the silver puck but reverted back to the stock saddle. With this configuration, my new imaging deck clears easily. In fact, I am able to safely slew the RA axis over 45 degrees past the meridian on either side of the mount, effectively ending the need to do meridian flips half way through an imaging series.


Balancing - Without the additional weight of a telescope, the GM-8 is not able to balance correctly with the 7 lb counterweight fitted to the shaft, even if positioned as far up as possible. In the photos, you can see that I have added three 1 pound weights to the imaging deck. These are end-shaft counterweights for an Orion Atlas. I believe they have 6mm threaded posts. I bolted these from below with the posts facing up. On the top-most two weights, I removed the posts and re-threaded the upper half of the hole to 1/4"-20. I then attached a pair of Orion/Synta finder shoes (Scopestuff #RDPQ), each with a single centered 1/4"-20 bolt. I mounted a red-dot finder on the inner shoe and an Orion Magnificent Mini AutoGuider on the outer shoe. Use of these centered bolts makes it easy to adjust the pointing direction of the finder and guider.


Cabling - The camera and guider require a total of four cables, plus an additional two if I add the dew heater straps. To keep the cables under control, I enclosed these in a 1/2" Nylon expandable braided sleeve from the local electronics store. Strapping this to the Vixen saddle knob with a Velcro strap and pointing it off to the right side ensured that it did not snag on anything as I slewed across the sky. This cable bundle is shown in the photo below. It works both with the camera rotated on its side, as shown, or with the cable ports pointing up. I am not able to rotate the camera with the ports facing down with this system.


Communications - The cable bundle is routed down and strapped to the RA/DEC cable bundle as shown below. The two USB cables are connected to a 4-port powered hub. The RJ-25 cable from the auto-guider plugs directly into the Gemini board. The AC power adapter for the QSI is strapped to the tripod leg below the hub. In addition to the two camera connections, an FTDI USB-Serial adapter is plugged into the hub to connect the laptop to Gemini control board. As well, a TEMPerHum PC temperature and humidity sensor is plugged into the hub allowing me to monitor ambient temperature and dew-point to get an idea of when I might need to refocus.


Computer and Software - My Windows 7 laptop rests on a ledge made from a large kitchen cutting board and attached to the tripod leg of the GM-8 mount. I run the following software during and after imaging sessions:
  • PHD Guider - Auto-guiding with the Orion Starshoot.
  • Astro Photography Tool - Temperature monitoring, camera focusing and control, image framing, image acquisition.
  • SkyTools 3 - Session planning, star atlas, target selection, logging.
  • ASCOM Gemini Driver and POTH Hub - Simultaneous connection of APT and SkyTools to the GM-8.
  • DeepSkyStacker - Calibrating and stacking images.
  • Photoshop CS5 - Post-processing


Imaging Result - The image below of the Butterfly Nebula and Crescent Nebula was composed of two 30 minute exposures taken through an Astronomiks 12nm H-alpha filter. These were calibrated with three dark and bias frames. I am pleased with the results. The Canon EF 70-200mm f/4L lens at the long focal length produces great stars across the field of view. As expected, the stars are somewhat under-sampled, even at 200mm.


I am not seeing the pinched shape on bright stars which I have observed before with this lens wide open. I wonder if the effect is not with the lens but with the DSLR. I did see a pronounced reflection halo around the bright star Sadr. Below is a enlarged view of the effect. On the left is an enlargement of Sadr from the picture above. On the right is an enlargement of Alniyat from the image of Rho Ophiuci in the previous post. I have adjusted the relative sizes to show equivalent image-scales. The DSLR at 4.3um has much finer pitch than the QSI at 7.4um. In the QSI image, the center of the frame is to the upper right. In the DSRL image, the center of the frame is slightly down and to the right. The dark pinched region is always oriented circumferentially.


Focusing and Stopping - With this CCD adapter, it is not possible to close the iris of an EF lens as this requires the electronics in the DSLR camera. Until I rig some sort of external stop, I have to image with the lens wide open. Fortunately, this particular zoom lens has good wide open performance, except for this pinching effect on the brightest stars.

The lack of electronic focus control is a much bigger issue. Like most EF lenses, manually focusing on stars is feels more like squeezing the focusing ring than twisting it. Nonetheless, using a Bahtinov mask and focusing on Sadr, I was able to get the diffraction pattern centered within a few minutes. Using 3 second exposures on a small region-of-interest, a feature recently added to Astro Photography Tool, made this task tractable.

Saturday, July 26, 2014

Rho Ophiuchi at Canyon of Eagles

This evening was another Austin Astronomical Society members-only star party at Canyon of Eagles. I went with the goal of trying to re-image the Rho Ophiuchi Nebula. My last attempt, in August 2013 using the same camera and lens, was a disappointment due to image noise.

This time, I used my homemade cooler box and made sure I took a series of dark frames. My ISO and aperture settings were the same as last year, as was the total integration time. However, in an attempt to further reduce noise, I halved the individual exposure times to 300 seconds, enough to detach the histograms from the black-point. With an ambient temperature of about 85F, I was able to cool the camera enclosure down to a steady 66F. The noise had the same diagonally-banded characteristics but at a lower level. This allowed me to boost the shadows more before the noise became problematic. All image acquisition control via Astro Photography Tool.

I am considering purchase of an adapter to connect my QSI-540ws directly to the Canon lens; there is still no comparison between the noise level of the astronomical camera and a DSLR.

Rho Ophiuchi - Canon 60Da / Canon EF 70-200mm f/4L - 28 x 300s, ISO-800, 200mm, f/4.
Thanks to Dave and Ed, my neighbors for the evening, for sharing visual views through the large Dobsonian.

Saturday, July 12, 2014

Highland Mall Purple Martin Roost

After Danielle saw a post on the Birds of Texas Facebook page, we drove down to the Highland Mall in Austin to see the Purple Martin Roost that occurs here each summer. According to members of the Travis Audubon Society, which leads field trips to the mall, tens of thousands of martins roost in a few trees as they stage for their migration down to Brazil. The cluster of trees in which the martins are roosting this year is circled below



We arrived in the parking log behind Jack in the Box on the north side of the mall around 7:30 PM. Initially, we saw martins arriving in small group, swooping over our heads. This gave me some practice photographing birds in flight such as this female Purple Martin.

Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L - 400mm, f/7.1, 1/320s, ISO-400
As sunset approached, the waves of birds became larger and larger. Per the suggestion of the Travis Audubon Society, many spectators were sporting umbrellas to keep off the droppings. At sunset, the birds began to settle into the roosting trees. Unlike the spectacle of Mexican Free-tailed Bats, the birds do not stream like smoke trails. Rather, they circle and swoop in bunches, not nearly as tight as Starlings, but still very impressive. Especially so as I realized that these were Purple Martins which I have only ever seen in small groups.

Single frame extracted from iPhone 5 movie
Single frame extracted from Canon 60Da movie
This short video clip does not do justice to the number of birds. Next time, I need to bring a wide-angle lens!


After dark, we moved up closer to the roost for a better view and were able to stand right next to the low trees. Wow, it was like a solid wall of birds - each new arrival trying to find a spot to roost was greeted by irate neighbors staking out their spot. The air was thick with the smell of droppings which covered the ground below.

Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L - 135mm, f/8, 1/100s, ISO-800, (Flash)
Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L - 400mm, f/16, 1/100s, ISO-800, (Flash)
I notice that some of the birds have orange mouths and some pink mouths. I have read that baby martins have bright orange mouths that serve as a beacon for the parents to drop food into in their dark nest cavities. I wonder if the orange-mouthed bird below is a juvenile.

Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L - 400mm, f/8, 1/100s, ISO-800, (Flash)

Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L - 285mm, f/16, 1/100s, ISO-800, (Flash)
Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L - 285mm, f/16, 1/100s, ISO-800, (Flash)
On the whole, an amazingly social bunch of birds to tolerate such close proximity. They eventually began to settled down for the night as we and the last of the spectators packed up around 9:30 PM.


Western Kingbirds Bickering in Flight

While waiting for the Purple Martin roosting event at the Highland Mall in Austin, I saw this pair of Western Kingbirds fighting their way across the parking lot. They remained in this relative position with the scruffy looking upper bird harassing the lower bird.

Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L - 250mm, f/7.1, 1/1600s, ISO-400
Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L - 250mm, f/7.1, 1/1600s, ISO-400
I am not positive of my identification, but settled on the Western Kingbird based on the yellow belly, pale gray head with lighter throat and, especially, the white edge on the tail.

Tuesday, July 1, 2014

Rock Wren at Lake Georgetown

This is the second time we have seen this bird just below the dam of Lake Georgetown. Though we are east of its normal zone, we are fairly certain that this is a Rock Wren based on appearance and call. Sibley shows our location as rare for this bird.

Canon SX-50 HS - 215mm, f/6.5, 1/320 sec, ISO-640

Canon SX-50 HS - 215mm, f/6.5, 1/320 sec, ISO-800

Saturday, June 21, 2014

Milkweed for the Butterflies

Danielle and I went to Hill Country Water Gardens this afternoon to get some plants for the yard. We picked up some Tropical Milkweed to add to the seedlings of Green Antelopehorn Milkweed we already have. Although Tropical Milkweed is a South American native plant, it is a host plant for some butterfly caterpillars, and the ones we saw at the nursery were attracting several butterflies. We initially thought these were Monarch Butterflies, but on closer examination, they were Soldier Butterflies. The Monarch has much bolder black veining in the wings and a black trailing boarder on the forewings. The very similar Queen Butterfly lacks the white spots on the hindwings.

Milkweed is a necessary food source for the Monarch caterpillars; the Green Antelopehorn Milkweed is the preferred native milkweed in Texas, as the toxins in the plant make the butterflies inedible to many predators, but Tropical Milkweed is still a very attractive plant.

Soldier Butterfly - iPhone 5 -  4mm, f/2.4, 1/753 sec, ISO-50